Home
Council on Energy, Environment and Water Integrated | International | Independent
REPORT
Accelerating Investments for Nature-based Solutions in the Global South
A Unified Framework for Mapping and Estimating Benefits
06 August, 2024 | Climate Resilience
Shreya Wadhawan and Aryan Bajpai

Suggested citation: Wadhawan, Shreya, and Aryan Bajpai. 2024. Accelerating investments towards Nature-based Solutions in the Global South - A Unified Framework for Mapping and Estimating Benefits. New Delhi: Council on Energy, Environment and Water.

Overview

Nature-based solutions (NbS) have significant potential to mitigate climate impacts and enhance resilience by utilising natural processes and ecosystems. However, for NbS to be effective, they must be implemented and scaled appropriately, especially in vulnerable regions. This study aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of NbS and the challenges associated with their scaling and implementation in the Global South. To address these challenges, the study introduces ENSURE - Effective Nature-based Solutions Utilisation and Resource Evaluation framework designed to map and estimate the benefits of NbS. This proposed framework has three components: first, the identification and categorisation of interventions as NbS; second, the demarcation of the benefits associated with the identified interventions; and third, the estimation of the cost-to-benefit ratio, providing a standardised approach to assess and report on the outcomes and costs of NbS. This framework is intended to drive investments, enable stakeholders to scale up interventions effectively, and maximise the impact of NbS in mitigating climate change and enhancing resilience in vulnerable regions.

Key Highlights

  • The study finds that, thus far, NbS has largely been implemented in developed countries, which are equipped with the tools and data necessary to assess their potential.
  • A systematic review highlights two main categories of gaps and challenges for NbS in the Global South: Implementation barriers exist particularly due to a lack of knowledge and tools in developing countries, and investment barriers exist due to poorly established market value and uncertainties around returns and benefits for NbS.
  • The study emphasises the role of local factors of influence (LFI) in the success of NbS implementations. These factors include social, economic, cultural, environmental, livelihood-related, and species-related aspects that can influence and be influenced by NbS interventions.
  • A one-size-fits-all approach can hamper the scaling and implementation of specific NbS initiatives.
  • ENSURE has seven components that are essential for conducting a comprehensive economic assessment of an NbS intervention and implementing it.

HAVE A QUERY?

“Nature-based solutions hold immense potential to address climate challenges and enhance resilience. However, to fully realise their benefits, it is crucial to implement a unified framework that can accurately map and estimate their impacts. While there have been similar efforts and frameworks in other parts of the world, this is a novel effort for the Global South, specifically addressing their unique needs. This approach will drive strategic investments, inform stakeholders, and enable the effective scaling of these solutions, particularly in vulnerable regions.”

Executive Summary

Over the last two decades, a staggering 750 million South Asians, representing over half of the region’s population, have experienced the impacts of various natural disasters such as floods, droughts, and cyclones. Projections indicate that if current patterns persist, the Global South is poised to incur an average annual loss of USD 160 billion by 2030 due to climate impacts, implying that this region, in particular, is disproportionately vulnerable to the effects of climate change (World Bank 2022). Therefore, it is crucial to develop effective strategies to enhance resilience and mitigate the impacts. An effective approach to mitigating climate impacts in the developing world is deploying nature-based solutions (NbS). NbS encompass a broad range of strategies that utilise natural processes and ecosystems to reduce flooding, sequester carbon, preserve biodiversity, and enhance living standards by providing fresh air, clean water amongst others. NbS have the potential to cost-effectively achieve around 30 per cent of the mitigation needed by 2030 to stabilise the global temperature increase to below 2°C (IUCN 2019).

Although the benefits of NbS are recognised globally, their financing and implementation often fall short of proposed targets. The global market for NbS is valued at between USD 125 and USD 300 billion annually (WEF 2020), but it receives only about USD 200 billion in investments per year, with the private sector contributing merely 18 per cent. Further, high-income countries, such as those in North America and Europe, receive the lion’s share of NbS investments, accounting for approximately 75 per cent of the total (UNEP 2022).

In contrast, low-income countries receive only a small fraction of NbS investments, despite being more vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. The absence of standardised measures and reporting on the impacts of NbS make it difficult to evaluate their effectiveness and, consequently, hinder investments in this sector and the scaling up of successful projects. A lack of expertise and methodologies for mapping benefits further discourages investments in NbS in the Global South. Thus, the need of the hour is a common assessment framework that can help stakeholders evaluate the economic and non-economic benefits of NbS.

This report provides a comprehensive understanding of NbS, details the difficulties associated with scaling and implementing such solutions, and proposes a framework to map and estimate the benefits of NbS in the Global South. This framework will allow users to:

a) identify an intervention as an NbS,

b) demarcate its benefits, and

c) estimate the cost-to-benefit ratio by providing a standardised approach to assess and report on their outcomes and costs.

Conducting due diligence before implementing NbS projects will help drive investments in the sector, allow stakeholders to scale up such interventions, and maximise impact in the long run.

Figure ES1 The benefits of investing in nature-based solutions

ENSURE - A unified framework for mapping and estimating the benefits of nature-based solutions

ENSURE - Effective Nature-based Solutions Utilisation and Resource Evaluation framework comprises three thoughtfully designed categories, each with sub- components, to guide stakeholders through the mapping and estimation process.

Category 1: Identification and categorisation of NbS

This category comprises a five-point criteria that will allow users to examine whether an identified intervention is an NbS. The criteria is essential to ensuring that interventions are contextually relevant and beneficial for the region of implementation, keeping in mind its socio-economic and geographical characteristics. The criteria will also help ensure that interventions align with the principles of sustainable development.

Category 2: Checklist for the implementation of the identified solution

NbS implementation outcomes vary based on geography, scale, and stakeholder involvement – elements collectively termed as ‘local factors of influence’ (LFI). Here, ‘local’ refers to contextual rather than spatial influences. This step helps users understand complex relationships across six categories of factors: social, environmental, species-related, economic, livelihood-related, and cultural. These factors can affect the implementation process positively or negatively. Thus, users must identify these relationships through stakeholder consultations and literature reviews to make informed decisions and discover opportunities for enhancing the impact of NbS.

Category 3: Establishing the investment potential of NbS

Finally, mapping the costs and benefits associated with an NbS project helps lay the groundwork for its successful implementation. This process, which broadly involves cost mapping across four major categories and benefit mapping across seven categories, is essential for establishing the scale and scope of the project. Further, our framework also helps users identify the ecosystem valuation method most suited to estimate the economic value of a desired benefit based on the availability of resources and data. This method will help users accurately and cost-effectively determine the economic value of a given intervention. Figure ES2 provides an overview of the framework and the various steps essential for its accurate implementation.

Figure ES2 An overview of ENSURE - a unified framework for mapping and estimating the benefits of nature-based solutions in the Global South

Applications of the framework

The framework for mapping the benefits of NbS has diverse applications across various sectors, empowering key stakeholders to drive sustainable change.

  • For government agencies, ENSURE provides standardised techniques for data collection, analysis, and reporting. It may also be useful for those involved in the Natural Capital Accounting and Valuation of Ecosystem Services (NCAVES) project. This framework can improve the precision and comparability of natural capital assessments, thus allowing for more informed decision-making regarding sustainable resource management and economic growth. Furthermore, by allowing agencies to map the climate co-benefits of the outcomes of programmes such as the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS), it will support them in planning interventions that help disadvantaged communities become more resilient to climate change by offering prospects for establishing sustainable livelihoods. Additionally, it will help governments meet the targets they have set for themselves under their Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) by making it easier to quantify the contributions of NbS in reducing emissions and by assisting in the formulation of climate action programmes.
  • For private entities, ENSURE helps in understanding and quantifying the environmental and economic co-benefits of NbS. It enables companies to make informed investment decisions and leverage mechanisms such as green credits in alignment with their sustainability goals. The tradable green credits generated through NbS projects can contribute to market-based environmental initiatives, thereby creating new revenue streams and fostering sustainable practices.
  • Implementation agencies can benefit remarkably from our framework by gaining standardised approaches for identifying and monitoring projects. This will lead to more effective and accountable project implementation through the availability of guidelines on selecting appropriate NbS interventions based on ecological and socio- economic factors. Moreover, the framework will enable implementation agencies to communicate the wide range of benefits accrued through NbS projects, including social, economic, and health benefits, in addition to environmental advantages. This comprehensive understanding of outcomes will help drive stakeholder support and attract funding for NbS initiatives.

In conclusion, the ENSURE framework offers a comprehensive, one-stop solution for planning, implementing, and monitoring the outcomes of NbS projects. By providing detailed steps and guidelines, this framework equips decision-makers, practitioners, and communities with the tools needed to harness the potential of NbS, to create a more sustainable and resilient future, in particular, for the Global South.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are nature-based solutions (NbS)?

    NbS actions to protect, conserve, restore, sustainably use and manage natural or modified terrestrial, freshwater, coastal and marine ecosystems, which address social, economic and environmental challenges effectively and adaptively while simultaneously providing well-being, ecosystem services, resilience and biodiversity benefits. (UNEA, 2022) Nature-based solutions (NbS) are strategies that utilise natural processes and ecosystems to address environmental challenges, such as climate change, water security, and biodiversity loss. These solutions include actions like wetland restoration, reforestation, and the creation of green urban spaces that not only provide ecological benefits but also enhance human well-being and resilience. Global case studies demonstrate the multifaceted benefits of well-implemented NbS, including ecosystem services like climate regulation and disaster risk reduction, and socio-economic benefits such as job creation and improved human well-being. These case studies highlight best practices and lessons learned that can be applied to NbS initiatives in different regions, including the Global South.

  • Why is there a need for a unified framework for NbS?

    A unified framework for NbS is essential to standardise the assessment and reporting of their benefits and costs. This framework helps in identifying and categorising interventions, mapping their benefits, and estimating cost-to-benefit ratios. It enables stakeholders to make informed decisions, drive strategic investments, and scale up effective NbS interventions, particularly in regions with limited resources.

  • What are the main challenges in implementing NbS in the Global South?

    The main challenges include implementation barriers due to a lack of knowledge and tools among stakeholders and investment barriers because the market value of NbS interventions is poorly established. Additionally, uncertainties around the returns and benefits of these solutions make it difficult for implementation agencies and investors to commit resources.

  • What is the significance of local factors of influence (LFI) in NbS implementation?

    Local factors of influence (LFI) play a crucial role in the success of NbS interventions. These factors include social, economic, cultural, environmental, livelihood-related, and species-related aspects that can influence and be influenced by NbS. Understanding and integrating these local factors ensure that NbS interventions are tailored to the specific needs and conditions of the area, thereby enhancing their effectiveness and sustainability.

  •  

HAVE A QUERY?

Sign up for the latest on our pioneering research

Explore Related Publications